If 51% of elected politicians in some jurisdiction agree that women who will die of their pregnancies should not be allowed to abort the fetus to save their lives, how is that *self* determination for the women involved? It seems to me that this is "self" determination in much the same way that the right to own slaves is "freedom".
I thought that the point of abortion rights *was* self-determination. Going down from federal-level rights to state-level rights or restrictions does localize the issue somewhat, but it is far from giving local communities the right to decide for themselves. If a local, small community wants to ban abortion for their members, that can honor the members’ right to self-determination as the community can get to know the members’ individual needs and concerns in a way that no state or country or even county can. Personally, though I would describe myself as leftist, I am against abortion for myself. I just think it would pain me a lot to let go of the potential of life that a fetus represents. I think a lot of abortion rights advocacy that focuses on empowering pregnant people to choose abortion can fail to acknowledge how difficult it can be to decide to let go of a fetus, and also how valid it is, from an individual standpoint, to be even staunchly against that option. But I do honor self-determination, and I would never tell someone not to have an abortion based on my own opinion.
I'm confused.
If 51% of elected politicians in some jurisdiction agree that women who will die of their pregnancies should not be allowed to abort the fetus to save their lives, how is that *self* determination for the women involved? It seems to me that this is "self" determination in much the same way that the right to own slaves is "freedom".
I thought that the point of abortion rights *was* self-determination. Going down from federal-level rights to state-level rights or restrictions does localize the issue somewhat, but it is far from giving local communities the right to decide for themselves. If a local, small community wants to ban abortion for their members, that can honor the members’ right to self-determination as the community can get to know the members’ individual needs and concerns in a way that no state or country or even county can. Personally, though I would describe myself as leftist, I am against abortion for myself. I just think it would pain me a lot to let go of the potential of life that a fetus represents. I think a lot of abortion rights advocacy that focuses on empowering pregnant people to choose abortion can fail to acknowledge how difficult it can be to decide to let go of a fetus, and also how valid it is, from an individual standpoint, to be even staunchly against that option. But I do honor self-determination, and I would never tell someone not to have an abortion based on my own opinion.